The present wife did not become unlawful because of a kullama oath
Question
A dispute arose between Zayd and Bakr over the sale and purchase of some item. Zayd says: “We paid the price of the goods sold,” and Bakr says: “You did not pay the price.” Then Zayd, the buyer, and Bakr, the seller, both took their case before a religious scholar, and both parties made that scholar their arbiter (hakam).
Answer
(1–4) Because Zayd swore this oath, his present wife has not become unlawful for Zayd; however, if in future he marries any woman, talaq will take effect. فالحاصل أن كلما لعموم الأفعال وعموم الأسماء ضروري، فيحنث بكل فعل “The upshot is that kullama is for the generality of acts, and the generality of nouns is necessary; so he breaks the oath with every act” (Shami, Nu‘maniyya…
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.