What is the reason for the dislike of the imamate of those whose imamate is makruh?
Question
[There is the] text: والأولى بالإمامة الأعلم بالسنة، ثم الأقرأ، ثم الأورع، ثم الأسن، فإن أمَّ عبد أو أعرابي أو فاسق أو أعمى أو مبتدع أو ولد الزنا كُره “The most entitled to the imamate is the one most knowledgeable of the sunna, then the best reciter (aqra’), then the most scrupulous (awra‘), then the eldest. If a slave, a Bedouin (a‘rabi), a fasiq, a blind man, a mubtadi‘ (innovator) or one born of zina leads the prayer, it is makruh.
Answer
If this blind man is careful in matters of purity (tahara) and is superior [to the others], his imamate is not makruh: the Messenger of Allah ﷺ appointed Hadrat Ibn Umm Maktum ﵁ as imam in blessed Madina when he set out on a journey. As for the fasiq and the mubtadi‘, even if he is an ‘alim and a qari, his imamate will still be makruh. Concerning the slave, the Bedouin (a‘rabi)
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.