The imamate of a man whose hand has been cut off
Question
(1) What is the ruling on the imamate of a man whose hand has been cut off (maqtu' al-yad)? (2) If people prayed behind him for a long time, and afterwards some self-seeking people, for some reason, raising the charge that his hand is cut off, themselves refuse to pray behind him and also stop others — how far is this correct? [We request that] the signatures of most of the prominent scholars be affixed. (20 Jumada al-Akhira 1355 AH)
Answer
If that person performs purification and cleanliness properly and takes care over it, his imamate is valid according to the Shari'a; otherwise it is makruh. The imamate of a healthy and sound person is in any case preferable (awla). وكذا تكره خلف أمرد وسفيه ومفلوج وأبرص، فالاقتداء بغيره أولى. تاترخانية. وكذا أجذم ومجبوب وحاقن ومن له يد واحدة. فتاوى الصوفية عن التحفة.
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.