The opening takbir while sitting in a fard prayer
Question
If a person, without an excuse, says the takbir al-tahrima of a fard prayer while sitting and immediately stands up, will his prayer be valid or not?
Answer
لو قال المصنف: فرضها التحريمة قائمًا، لكان أولى، لأن الافتتاح لا يصح إلا في حالة القيام، حتى لو كبر قاعدًا ثم قام لا يصير شارعًا، لأن القيام فرض حالة الافتتاح “Had the author said, ‘Its fard is the tahrima while standing,’ it would have been better, because the opening [of the prayer] is valid only in the standing position; so that if he said the takbir while sitting and then…
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.