Guardianship in Nikah: the Mother or the Paternal Half-Brother?
Question
What do the scholars of religion and the muftis of the firm Shari‘a say regarding this matter: Zayd married, and from this wife two sons were born. After that this wife died, and Zayd took a second wife, from whom two children were born — a son and a daughter — and Zayd passed away. Now what needs to be ascertained is: who has the guardianship in nikah of this minor girl and minor boy — their mother or their adult paternal half-brothers?
Answer
A minor boy and girl can neither conclude their own nikah themselves nor become guardians of each other. ولا ولاية لعبد ولا صغير ولا مجنون لأنه لا ولاية لهم على أنفسهم فأولى أن لا تثبت على غيرهم “There is no guardianship for a slave, a minor or an insane person, since they have no guardianship over themselves, so all the more is it not established over others” (“al-Hidaya”,…
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.