Verses of a Poet-Imam About Himself
Question
What fatwa, by the Sacred Law, the Qur’an and hadith, falls upon such a poet-imam? His whole poem follows: کون آئے گا ثانی میرا میرے بعد ٭ کون پہونچائے گا پیغام وفا میرے بعد “Who will come as my second after me? Who will convey the message of fidelity after me?” پھول کی طرح جس ایک شاخ پہ بیٹھا برسوں ٭ کیوں نہ ترسے گی گلستاں کی فضا میرے بعد “On the one branch where I sat for years like a flower — why should the garden’s air not pine after me?
Answer
It is the very nature of poetry to praise oneself; that is why the righteous did not take up poetry. Nonetheless, nowhere in the verses quoted is there a claim to prophethood — only poetic vehemence, which is unbecoming; but no severe ruling (kufr and the like) can be applied to him.
Source: Fatawa Mahmudiyya
Preview. The full text opens with JavaScript enabled.